Saturday, 16 November 2013

Silly scientific titles – or – Interdisciplinary vade mecum of contemporary scientific terminology and comprehensive nomenclature conventions: an example from comparative in situ geomorphometric transnecrotism


I just love making up ridiculous scientific-sounding nonsense titles! And it’s really easy if you have just been exposed to enough real, serious titles and scientific terms, and add a bit of creative sarcasm.

And what is even more fun is when I make up a title that is actually not entirely nonsense, but it sounds hilarious anyway. For example, my good friend Nigel asked me for advice on a topic to give a speech about, and, knowing that he is not fond of mammal paleontology, I suggested “mammalian cranial morphological innovations in the late Eocene and implications for stratigraphic bias”.

So, I thought today I could just spark some ideas of how to design your own excruciatingly protracted titulary grammatical units.

Long words always help. Take the longest, most complicated synonym for a word you can find. If they are esoteric, even better! An easy way of making words longer and more esoteric-sounding is by adding typical scientific pre- and suffixes, such as:

  • inter-
  • intra-
  • trans-
  • micro-
  • macro-
  • psycho-
  • neuro-
  • synchro-
  • proto-
  • -ology
  • -morphology
  • -morphism
  • -osis
  • -metric

… and many others I cannot think of at the moment

Naturally, you should try to use these thoughtfully, so you don’t end up making words such as neuroconcertmorphology, because, although hilarious in isolation, they may fail to convey the sarcastic seriousness an ideal scientific nonsense title should have. Perhaps neurocortical concert-affiliated osteomorphology, or transneurotic concertational morphometrology are better candidates, but again, I can understand if these would be too ridiculous too.

I think another hint is to use many big words, but say nothing. Neurocortical concert-affiliated osteomorphology could be an example of this. It can of course be developed by adding more restriction words, to narrow the nonsense down to an even more incomprehensive level: Transatlantic neurocortical concert-affiliated osteomorphology of basal cervids from the Younger Dryas. This title is about the concert-related bone structure associated with the part of the brain that processes sensory information, in primitive deers from one of the glacial periods, making a comparison across the Atlantic ocean. You might want to skip the concert bit to make the title more serious; it is up to you, really.

I don’t think there is much else to tell for now. My final suggestion is to practice, and immerse yourself in weird titles every day, and soon you’ll be an expert in silly scientific titles.

Friday, 15 November 2013

Crazy plant genetics



Although I’m not usually that keen on genetics, I can’t but be mesmerised by the awesome genetic ability of plants.

Since my genetics class before university was mostly focused on animals, I tended to forget that, being so different to animals at the anatomical and physiological level, plants are something else entirely in terms of genetics too.

I repeat: genetics is not my thing. Therefore, I will not have the confidence to go into any detail here, but if this grabs your attention – which I hope it does – it would be fun if you tried out my tips for researching, in a recent post.

First of all, plants are experts at asexual reproduction, i.e. cloning themselves, sort of like most bacteria and other unicellular organisms do, but more complicated. A perhaps familiar example of how they do this is vegetative propagation, basically spreading out underground roots wherefrom new plant individuals bud out. This ability helps them to quickly colonise a new area.

Now, I know for myself that I would instinctively think that cloning does not have much to do with genetics, since it is just making a copy of everything. The genetics we learned about in class was all about sexual reproduction, which is mixing genetic material from both parents into an offspring and how that works.

Cloning sounds simple in comparison. However, at university, we have learned quite a bit about gene activation – different genes being turned on at different times. This is crucial for animals, since our bodies change as we age: some genes are turned on early, others later, and some are turned off after a certain time. But, try to imagine the gene activation mechanism required for creating a clone of a complex, multicellular organism. In animals, the offspring starts from zero, (mostly) unattached to the parents, whereas the plant clones literally grow out of their parent, which is already developed enough. I may just be wrong, but I think that the clones quickly catch up with their parent in development, which means their gene activation sequence must be different. (They are clones in the sense that they have the same total set of genes – the same genome – but the way these genes are activated is what determines what the individual will look like, so if they are used differently, the clones can become radically different, or, in this case, similar even though they should be at different developmental stages. In basic genetic jargon, we would say the clones have the same genotype, but may have different phenotypes, whereas in this case, they would be expected to have different phenotypes, but they purposefully don’t.)

Plants are of course also able to reproduce sexually, which is how they adapt to their environment in a selective way, rather than by random mutation. A mutation is a spontaneous change in the genome of an organism. Some are quite familiar to us, such as the trisomy 21, or three copies of chromosome 21, in humans, which causes Down’s syndrome. I mention this mutation in particular because it shows that mutations are not limited to some gene bases being copied wrong, resulting in a different protein, but also includes accidents in cell division, where the genes may not have separated as they should. In trisomy 21, of the four copies of chromosome 21 that are meant to split evenly into the four sperm cells, a par did not separate, so one sperm ended up with two, and another one without a chromosome 21. If the sperm with the extra chromosome 21 enters the egg, which has its own copy of chromosome 21, the foetus will most likely develop trisomy 21.

This example results in an unfortunate condition for the child, but some of these mutations can work wonders. Most big leaps in evolution are thought to have been caused by large (and lucky) mutations of this kind.

While such crazy genetics can cause harm, or, as in most cases, prevent the zygote (fertilised egg) from developing at all, or maybe not have any effect at all, on the rare occasion, it produces something entirely novel. The Cambrian explosion, an event in the very early stages of animal evolution, saw a myriad of radically different animals emerge, so different from one another that the experts have no clue of how to classify many of them. It might have been full of such mutation events. (Hadn’t thought of that until writing this post actually, but it has given me something to think about now!)

In plants, at least two radical mutations of this sort have marked the rise of a whole new type of plants, which today dominate the flora. These mutations were even more crazy than getting and extra chromosome, though: they experienced a whole-genome duplication, i.e. a doubling of all chromosomes, all genes. I doubt any animal species would survive this, at least not with fertile offspring that could spread it to following generations – but plants did this twice, and moulded it into their perhaps greatest evolutionary inventions! I think they deserve an applause for this!!

The first whole-genome duplication event in plants occurred in the Late Carboniferous (Pennsylvanian), about 320 million years ago, and resulted in the emergence of seed plants, i.e. plants which encase their sexually produced offspring in a protective capsule, the seed, with enough moisture and nutrients to be able to lie dormant (‘inactive’) in the soil for long periods of time, enabling them to survive dry seasons and wait for optimal conditions before germinating into a seedling. The seed was perhaps the key innovation that freed the seed plants from their reproductive dependence on stable water bodies, and enabled plants to colonise land completely. Prior to this event, plants were only able to live by coasts and around nearby lakes, and, thus, animals were equally limited. The advent of seed plants enabled life to break free from the sea and move further inland, bringing complex life to all corners of the Earth. It turned out to be one of the most significant cornerstones in the history of life on this planet. How awesome isn’t that?!

The second time this happened, in the Early Jurassic period, roughly 190 million years ago, the world saw the first flowering plants, or angiosperms. (However, I remember reading a very recent article where scientist have found angiosperm-like pollen dating as far back as 240 million years ago, which is the Middle Triassic, so maybe this whole-genome duplication marked the emergence of more awesome angiosperms, or perhaps the dating methods are inaccurate.) The flowering plants are hugely important for us animals, since their strategy of recruiting animals to spread their seeds and pollen, helping them reproduce, means that they must be generous in providing nutritious rewards in the form of fruits and vegetables. (We also eat some of their seeds and roots, which the plants are not as happy about…) In other words, the flowering plants provide much better food for herbivores, which brings more easily available energy and nutrition to the food chain.

I have not yet read the paper about these whole-genome duplications, which I found ages ago, so I cannot give you much details. However, I am excited to learn more now, and I might just add another entry about this later. I hope it inspired you too. Respect plants!

Thursday, 14 November 2013

Biology field course next year

In our second year, we paleontology students at the University of Bristol get to do quite a lot of field work. We did a one-week trip focused on geological mapping just before term start. Around the end of April, we will have a fossil-oriented field trip for another week, which I am quite looking forward too!

We will also have a field trip with the biology class this year, since we are a so-called Joint Honours programme, meaning that we take classes from two departments, in our case the departments of Earth Sciences and Biological Sciences. We were given a choice among a wide range of field trips, laboratory workshops and even a public outreach project, and I have just found out which one I have been allocated to.

In early April next year, I will be going to Lagos, a town in the Algarve coast of southern Portugal. We will spend a week studying all sorts of plants, and how they are adapted to their environment! The first few days will be led by our supervisors, to familiarise us with the plants and the setting, to appreciate how we can study them, and to give us ideas for the independent group research project we will spend the remaining time on.

I'm quite thrilled to see what a biology field trip will be like, as I have never had a serious biology-focused excursion before. I am also excited to see the Mediterranean sea!

A gut feeling tells me I should get some new field gear – adapted for work under blazing sun, rather than pouring rain and freezing wind. Self-moisturising notebook, rather than a (hardly) water-resistant one. Lots of water. Moist snacks...

I'll have plenty of time to think about it!

Wednesday, 13 November 2013

3 tips to research a topic

This time, I feel like writing something a bit more practical. So, now I'll share with you my three main tools to researching a topic, in science in particular.

1. Check Wikipedia. Despite my university lecturers, tutors, school teachers, and family all tracking down on Wikipedia because "anyone can write it", I find no greater value in any other site when it comes to finding quick, basic information. Wikipedia has an excellent structure, far superior than any other searchable database I have come accross, and it is thanks to this structure that I know exactly where to find the information I am looking for four out of five times. If I want to look up a technical term, I just read the first one or two sentences, and those tell you exactly what the term means, and with a good feel for what it encompasses, you can go on to read other related texts and understand them. If I want to check details about a certain extinct group, such as time of origin, time of extinction, defining characteristics, etc., it can typically be found in the right margin box and/or a section with a title that gives you the clue.

The reason I would never cite Wikipedia in a serious essay or other work is because it is frowned upon by the senior academics in this world. Being naturally arrogant, these highly educated people instinctively look down on something 'less educated' people have written, and the idea that someone else might actually know better than them is probably heresy. Such close-mindedness irritates me more than I could express in decent language, so I won't go there. Another argument I typically hear for not using Wikipedia is that they don't cite any references. Whoever claims that clearly has not spent much time on Wikipedia, at least not the science-related part. In fact, Wikipedia is better referenced than most web-based information sources I am familiar with. I have occasionally used the Wikipedia reference section just to find relevant articles. Then I read and cite those articles in my work.

Maybe it is just because my default state is to trust until proven unworthy of trust, rather than the opposite, but I warmly recommend drawing on the knowledge of the commons for a broad overview of a topic.

If I want to go deeper, I typically go to the next two.

2. Scan the library. To be honest, I have only recently begun to explore the wealth of books in the library of our university, and feeling I have missed out, I wish I had started earlier. Most of our coursebooks are available in at least one or two copies, and I assume that is the aim of all university libraries. (I have not actually been in a public library in the UK, so I cannot speak for them.)

If I do not already know exactly which book I am looking for, scaning the shelfs for a good title is always a start. Having found something that looks promising, I tend to start with a check through the table of contents, and if that looks good, I might open the first chapter and start reading. If I enjoy the writing style and/or feel that its content is useful, I ask to loan it and take it home where I can read with my pen and note pad ready.

However, I have noticed that many of the books recommended for our courses are not as reader-friendly as one would expect them to be, since they are aimed at undergraduates. Being in general poorly written (in my opinion), it is unrewardingly difficult to extract useful information from them. Therefore, I am now moving toward resuming my old favourite method of reading scientific articles. Although these are aimed at other scientists, usually specialists in the topic concerned, and thus filled with technical jargon (which mostly can be looked up on Wikipedia), they have to be well-structured in order to be published, and as such much easier to scan for the information you are after.

3. Find specific articles on Google Scholar. Try to be as specific as you need. The clearer you have in mind precisely what it is you are after, the more you can narrow down your search by typing in keywords. For example, if you type in "dinosaurs", you'll get more than 100 000 results, and the top ones usually being the most popular ones, and pehaps not the most useful or interesting to you. But if you are curious about the chewing ability of primitive horned dinosaurs, and have done some background reading so you are familiar with some terms and phylogenetic group names, and type in "jaw mechanics of early protoceratopsids", you have narrowed it down to less than twenty hits, and a handful with promising-looking titles. If you then find that you want more, experiment with taking away some key words to broaden your search so you don't risk missing potentially important papers.

Google Scholar automatically has a lik saying PDF if there is a freely available downloadable version of the article. If not, you might need a subscription to the journal for access. As a student, I have access to the journals the university is subscribed to. If you are not a student, however, or your uni does not have access to the desired journal, ask around among your friends and acquaintances if there is someone you know who could access the PDF for you.


I hope you are willing to experiment with these sources, and find your own preference, because these are only advice from my personal experience, which is nowhere near exhaustive. Please use my tips, but remember to be open-minded and look into other methods as well, and be cautious and think critically about what you read. Good luck!

Tuesday, 12 November 2013

Are animals optimally adapted to their environment?

I have always had a strong distaste for the idea that animals are optimally adapted. Luckily, it doesn't seem to be a widely accepted concept, because if everything was optimally adapted to their surroundings, then everything living in the same environment should look exactly the same.

I might have just misinterpreted the concept, though, because I hope you agree with me that the idea sounds rather absurd otherwise...

Still, optimisation has been used quite a lot, in particular in paleontology. It is mainly used as a practical assumption to provide a framework for objective models, for example when studying how e.g. Tyrannosaurus rex moved. What I mean by that is that scientists use knowledge of physics and biomechanics, combined with measurements from the fossils, and put it in a big computer, which works out - by trial and error, I guess - the optimal movement style.

Therefore, one should take the results of such studies with a pinch of salt: they are not aiming to reflect the most likely reality, but aim to work out the best way to move. Or, if they were aiming to represent the most likely scenario, they probably missed the point. The optimisation assumption is accepted because it is a simple way of setting up a goal or framework for the mathematics to work toward.

It is exactly the same with the parsimony principle in phylogenetic trees of life we see everywhere today. The principle of parsimony, also known as Ockham's razor, states that the simplest explanation is the most useful to humanity. The word 'useful' is more important than I can emphasise. The simple theory is not more true, just more useful.

Now, part of the beauty of nature, which I'm sure most scientist would gladly advocate, is that nature is hugely complex. If you consider nature to be un-simple, and simultaneously accept assumptions that treat is as simple, you are being inconsistent.

Thus, when the evolutionary biologists are creating their phylogenetic trees of life, they are not working out the one that is most likely to be true, but the one that is the most simple, i.e. that can explain all the data with least twists and turns.

The only reason we accept these assumptions is that it allows us to work things out objectively and with common standards, if we all just agree to assume that the optimal model, or simplest solution, are the most likely to be true. We accept it because it is practical.

But the scientist leave that part out.

Today, in a lecture on evolutionary biology, we were told about an example where two traits that are genetically linked, i.e. always inherited together, make it impossible to reach an optimal solution, because that optimal state is having only one of those traits. The particular example is the strong positive relationship between beak depth and beak length in finches, and maybe other birds too. A deep – i.e. thick – beak is capable of delivering stronger force, and a shorter beak means that the force is distributed over a smaller area; thus, the optimal design would be deep and short, but you never get that because both traits are linked, so you either get a shallow and short or deep and long beak.

This is clear evidence that the optimisation assumption is flat out false. But we still accept it, because it is practical.

Monday, 11 November 2013

Failure

I'm writing this post in the note app on my phone; it's the first time I do something like this, but I literally won't have time to do it any other way. I have been to a TEDx conference (if you are not familiar with TED, I strongly recommend you to check up their website) in Bristol (I hope this link gets you to the recorded talks when/if they are published), which spanned a cross the whole day. Now I have a short time on my three 30 minute bus journeys back home for dinner and then straight back to university for a Public Speaking Society session, and finally back home again.

This is unusually busy for me, which I'm sure makes half of you laugh, but it is true. I'm not saying it is because I have no pressure on me - that is only half-true - but because i tend to be good at spreading out the pressure over several days.
Anyway, this was not the point here at all, I'm sorry. Rather, I wanted to write about the theme of the TEDx talks: failure.

But since this is a paleoblog, I'll angle the topic to failure in evolution. Can something fail in evolution? How? What are the consequences?
Well, there is a really simple answer to those questions, which I think I can sum up in one sentence that probably won't even need further explanation: Evolution is all about adapting to change, so failure in evolution would be failure to adapt, and results in a decline in the population, or flat out extinction, depending on the degree of failure.

More interesting perhaps, is considering evolutionary reversals from this perspective. Evolutionary reversals are simply when a lineage adapts back to a more ancestral state. Brilliant examples are several land vertebrate groups returning to an aquatic life (see Eyes and the emergence of predators) whack their ancestors had evolved away from 100s of million years earlier.

When we humans face failure in something, we tend to either become devastated and back off, or learn and try again with a different approach. Could this be an analogy for evolutionary reversals?
Did the land colonisers realise that getting onto land was a mistake, and go back to the water? Did flightless birds such as ratites and penguins think of flight as a mistake?

Although that probably not is the case (otherwise we'd expect all vertebrates to revert to an aquatic lifestyle, or all birds to lose their ability to fly), it is still quite thought-provoking. And the same reason why only some lineages in the groups made these reversals may even teach us one way of looking at failure: "what works for you might not work for me" i.e. where you succeed, I might not, and that's is nothing odd; and, where I have difficulties, you might excel.

Sunday, 10 November 2013

How did they drink?


I just have a hunch that most reconstructions of large dinosaurs, the sauropods in particular, can be shot down in flames by asking incredibly simple questions such as: ‘How did they drink?’ or ‘How did they sleep?’.

All animals need to drink more than they need to eat. However, since diets are incredibly varied across the animal kingdom, it is of great interest to researchers, not the least to paleontologists. Therefore, a lot of attention and discussion is focused on feeding, perhaps to the extent where we forget the more mundane essentials such as drinking and sleeping.

I get it. It is boring to ask how a colossal animal drank compared to how it could possibly have been able to eat enough food to grow this big, what type of food it ate, and how it ate it.

This may just be my impression, though. Perhaps the scientists do have all the essentials in mind when they model the skeletons of extinct animals. I may very well be mistaken.

But still…

Take the debate about if sauropods – the long-necked dinosaurs – could reach up to the highest tree crowns or not. Their clearly herbivorous diet and long necks intuitively suggest that they evolved to reach high. However, there are several problems with this.

First of all, raising a long neck high up would take considerable muscular effort, and would require the neck to be flexible, which further means that lots of muscles would be needed along most of the neck to hold it stable, at any height. Therefore, it has been suggested that the sauropods alternatively had stiff necks held just above ground level using elastic ligaments, which would not be able to elevate the neck, but keep it from falling without any energy effort.

But, while this seems to have gained wide acceptance (probably based on actual evidence of such ligaments on fossils, I guess), an idea that the sauropods might have stood up on their back legs, in order to reach higher, spread. Again, critics pointed to the fact that it would require enormous muscle work for an animal of that size to pesade, and to remain with all its weight on only its hind limbs. Some suggested that they could have used their tail as a third leg, assuming what is termed a tripodal posture. However, that would not really make the labour effortless.


My point is, it seems so much attention has gone to figuring out how they could reach up. I have not read a single comment about how they would have lowered their heads to drink water. Unless they drank from waterfalls or steep-sloped streams, they would have needed to get their heads down to ground level regularly.

Anyone who has gotten up from a sitting or lying position and felt dizzy is aware of the effect of raising your head too quick. Imagine raising your head 10 metres in a swipe. I think I wouldn’t get any blood to my brain and I’d faint halfway.

Maybe you think that the sauropods probably raised their heads very slowly. Consider, then, how vulnerable they would have been if approached by a predator while drinking?

Actually, that thought reminds me of what I read about giraffes: when they drink, they must spread their front legs in an incredibly awkward position, in which they are extremely vulnerable to e.g. lions, because they take too long to get up from that state. This is because the giraffe neck is stiff and its front limbs are longer than the hind limps. This is exactly the same design as in the sauropod Brachiosaurus (although not in many other sauropods) As an inevitable result, the neck cannot lower down comfortably, and they have to bend their bodies over.

Having that in mind, and that most sauropods had shorter forelimbs, I am happy to accept the idea that they had stiff necks held up by elastic ligaments, and muscles that were able to lift or sink it slightly. The forelimbs being shorter than the hindlimbs means that the neck would generally be angled down toward the ground. If we further consider the long neck as an adaptation to reach down to the ground without the need to bend the (still rather long) front leg, it can explain why they evolved their long neck in the first place. It challenges the intuitive assumption that the length of the neck evolved in response to pressure to reach higher than anyone else could reach. It implies that the sauropods may have grazed and browsed mainly 1-2 metres above ground level.

I really like that scenario, and I find it makes good sense.

There is still the question of Brachiosaurus and how that beast would have managed to drink. 

The take-home message of this post is about the need to think about the boring, yet essential aspects of all living organisms, if we want to truly understand their lives. We need to be open-minded and not get too buried in the exciting questions: you might even find an easy answer by looking at something else that seemed boring at first!